1. Restaurants
2. New York

Coletta

Reviews 543

• Anna K
  Sun, 18 Feb 2024 2:27
  That was my first time visiting a vegan restaurant. My friend is vegetarian and I have to say, it was an amazing experience. Everything that came out was delicious. The cheese board, steak tartar, special pasta, steak with mash potatoes, so good!!! I recommend it for everyone, even if you are not vegan. Service was super polite. Thank you so much.
• Alexandra Anderson
  Mon, 15 Jan 2024 3:07
  Wonderful vegan Italian food! I sat at the bar and service was excellent. The bartender gave me a few recommendations and I ended up ordering the crispy calamari appetizer and the fig and prosciutto pizza. I can’t recommend the calamari enough! Salty, chewy, acidic, and the sauces were a perfect compliment. If I lived locally, I would definitely visit here again.
• Heather Boswick
  Thu, 29 Feb 2024 17:10
  This place has a LOT of online hype so we visited for the first time & was BLOWN away! Coletta is a 100% all vegan Italian place with some of the BEST FOOD I’ve ever had! We made reservations for a Tuesday night. Upon entering, you are taken away by all the beautiful details. It’s a really beautiful space with such a nice ambience. The wait staff was amazing & super attentive & helpful with recommending dishes! What we got: - garlic knots. Came out beautifully presented with 6 nice sized garlic knots. They were the perfect texture complete with fresh herbs & olive oil. They were SO good! - Truffle mushroom pizza. It was a nice sized pizza that the two of us shared. This had to be one of the BEST vegan pizzas I’ve ever had (and I’ve dined at a lot of vegan pizza joints) The crust was perfect with either olive oil or butter which just made it extra flavorful! The cheese was perfectly melted complete with dollops of vegan ricotta. The mushrooms were generous & it has fresh herbs. Seriously, pizza lovers dream right here! - tiramisu. The vegan tiramisu here is the best vegan dessert I have EVER had. The “cream” on top was Devine. Layered with crumbled cookie (biscuit? Wasn’t sure but it was great) mixed with espresso & dark chocolate goodness. It was a nice size serving & hit the spot for dessert. I will forever dream of this tiramisu!! We are SO happy we chose Coletta for our dinner date. The ambience, the staff, the food, everything here is PERFECT! Every bite of food was perfect, delicious & worth all the online hype. This place is serving up amazing vegan Italian in the heart of the city where Italian food is king. Such a gem!
• Manan Shah
  Fri, 1 Dec 2023 18:42
  The ambience is nice. Perfect for a date night or celebrating birthday. We went for my wife’s birthday and the service was great. I did not like the food much though being a vegetarian. This is an expensive place and prices do not justify the dish. We only liked Rosemary bread with oil spreads.
• Mark Tobar
  Tue, 20 Feb 2024 20:37
  I want to preface this by saying I am not a huge fan of Italian food. I'm a long time vegan and my girlfriend and I had dinner here for that reason. We ordered the cheese board, chunk steak, chicken parmigiana, and tiramisu I struggled to believe that the foods we ordered were vegan, it might be easier to tell for someone who actually eats animal products but I was genuinely concerned because it was difficult for me to tell. The cheese board was great, my girlfriend and I both loved it besides the blue cheese but I think that's an acquired taste. The chunk steak was lacking a bit in flavor but I still very much enjoyed it. I do recommend trying the tiramisu as well, it was delicious We were sat in the corner opposite the large mirror, it was nice for us but some people may not be happy with that. We were 4 minutes late to our reservation, I hope that's not why they sat us there but we had an excellent time anyway. Kevin was a helpful server and other servers attended to us when he was busy so we never had to wait long for food or to order. He was very knowledgeable about the menu, I overheard him answering questions for another table Cheese board: definitely try Chunk steak: there are probably better items on the menu for less Chicken parmigiana: my gf was happy with it Tiramisu: my gfs favorite dessert, she loved it